MIM(Prisons) is a cell of revolutionaries serving the oppressed masses inside U.$. prisons, guided by the communist ideology of Marxism-Leninism-Maoism.
www.prisoncensorship.info is a media institution run by the Maoist Internationalist Ministry of Prisons. Here we collect and publicize reports of conditions behind the bars in U.$. prisons. Information about these incidents rarely makes it out of the prison, and when it does it is extremely rare that the reports are taken seriously and published. This historical record is important for documenting patterns of abuse, and also for informing people on the streets about what goes on behind the bars.
Bilal Sunni-Ali (13 July 1948 – 30 December 2024) was a revolutionary
and dedicated citizen of the Republic of New Afrika (RNA). That
dedication took various forms, from eir clandestine organizing to eir
contributions to revolutionary culture via eir jazz, blues, and spoken
word performances aimed at challenging the status quo and building up a
revolutionary nationalist consciousness among the people.
From eir youth, Bilal partook in pro-people activities from eir time
as a musician in the Youth Division of the North East Bronx NAACP, to
eir later activities as a founding member of the New York City Black
Panther Party fighting housing issues, police brutality, and recruiting
street L.O.s into the movement. Dedicated to the self-determination of
New Afrika, Bilal Sunni-Ali went underground in 1968 with the Black
Liberation Army. In 1982, ey would be charged and acquitted in RICO
charges related to the freeing of Assata Shakur and a bank robbery by
the Revolutionary Armed Task Force (RATF) for which Sekou
Odinga (who died 12 January 2024) and Silvia Baraldini were
convicted. Bilal was successfully defended by the late
Chokwe Lumumba in the politically charged trial, where they charged
the U.$. government with conspiracy on behalf of the RNA. The RATF is
described in detail in the book False Nationalism, False
Internationalism as the last attempt at the radical militancy of
the 1960s by members of the RNA and the Euro-Amerikan May 19th Communist
Organization. Prior to this, Bilal was locked up in Soledad prison from
1970-1972, where ey struggled to develop both the general and political
education of prisoners. Bilal’s support for prisoners continued
throughout eir life, as before eir recent death, ey was involved in the
Jericho Movement and the Imam Jamil Action Network – organizations
dedicated to the struggle of political prisoners.
Bilal was a devout Muslim who truly lived in accordance to eir faith
– not only by embodying the Islamic practice of standing up for the
oppressed, but by raising their consciousness at the same time; drawing
the connections between imperialism and white supremacy to the oppressed
youth.
Sifting through Bilal’s tenor saxophone performances online, one will
come across em performing at many events centered around prisoners. The
usual song of choice that ey perform is entitled “Look For Me In The
Whirlwind” (a title inspired by Marcus Garvey). The lyrics are as
follows:
War is never easy
its bound to bring to bring on hardship
its bound to make you weary
reach out for me
and war will have us parting
our paths are getting distant
we might not ever see each other again
until we win
until we win
so until then
until we win
look for me in the whirlwind
try try to see my face
in the whirlwind
try try to grab my hand
in the whirlwind
do all you can
to help your brotherman
through the whirlwind
reach out for me
reach out for me
reach out for me
for victory.
It is said that Bilal also went by the name “Spirit” and I believe
that to be an apt name for an individual who epitomizes the spirit of
eir people in all that ey do.
The methods of oppression are ever evolving to suppress the masses.
The people must realize that revolution and resistance is a science, not
rooted in emotion. Being a prisoner of war, enslaved by the state of
Illinois, I have learned that resistance to my oppression must be
calculated and strategic.
To all comrades held by the beast, learn the law! Stop allowing the
State to offer you meaningless distractions that prevent you from
fighting against this system. We must learn to use the weapons we got.
Understand, comrades, the pigs are trained and equipped to handle any
form of physical resistance, but they lack any true method to handle a
revolutionary mind.
Resist by challenging all conditions of your enslavement, use their
laws against them. Utilize every tool available to you. All peer
advocates/jailhouse lawyers must unite to teach all that they know.
Don’t let false titles keep us from uniting. Don’t let organizational
ties, race, ideological stance, or religion stop us from coming together
to fight against this system.
We must be organized and disciplined in our approach. Educate
yourselves, train your mind & bodies, read every day! Write every
day! Fuck that TV or tablet, get in the law library! All corporate media
is a lie! Unburden yourself from that illusion. A pig’s nature is to
consume uncontrollably, don’t be a pig or a pig sympathizer by allowing
their oppression of you to go unchecked! Master everything you commit
yourself to studying, revolutionize your mind. If the system doesn’t
fear your physicality, it fears your mind, or should I say, the
potential of what your mind can become!
“The heart of a soldier with the brain to teach a whole nation…”
2pac/No More Pain
My intentions here isn’t to give a dialectical and historical context
of the relationship between today’s Lumpen Organizations (gangs) and
past revolutionary movements, although there is an inextricable link
between the two. The origins of today’s Lumpen Organizations (L.O.s)
were strongly influenced by the original Black Panther Party (BPP) and
other similar organizations. They were formed to uplift and protect
their communities from outside threats, threats that were typically
imposed by law enforcement and the U.S. government.
With the destruction of the BPP, combined with the influx of drugs
and firearms within their already oppressed communities, members of
these organizations were lured into “gang-bangin’” against each other
and a fratricidal and suicidal criminal lifestyle that resulted in the
abandonment of the ideals and principles that were brought forth and
established by the organizations’ founders. Ideals and principles that
were often influenced by those of the BPP and the Black Liberation Army
(BLA). Today there are a limited few who diligently impress upon their
“homies” the importance of espousing the organizations founding ideals
and principles. Overall, a majority have been derailed from the
organizations initial revolutionary path, which has been detrimental to
the youth who romanticize today’s “gang” culture and their communities.
Moreover, the absence of these ideals and principles has engendered a
culture of disunity, violent competition, and the romanticizing of the
“gang-banging” mentality, which renders us incapable of redressing the
conditions we find ourselves subjected to within these razor-wire
plantations.
There is no silver bullet or magic wand that can be used to magically
expedite the transformation that must be made. Transforming the criminal
mentality into a revolutionary mentality is a protracted process that
demands accountability and rigorous educating.
i am dedicated to assisting with this transformation any way that i
can. One way is to shed some light on the draconian policies and
procedures that governs those of us who have been labeled “gang
members,” labels known as Security Risk Group (SRG) or Security Threat
Group (STG), so we can begin to seek redress to said policies and
procedures.
Gang Validation Process
Those of us who have been validated as SRG/STG often suffer
significant unfair prejudices due to the officers who are responsible
for the validating opinions often basing these opinions on sweeping
generalizations and stereotypes about “gang members” generally,
unreliable methodology, and/or the officer’s racial bias.
Here in North Carolina the Department of Adult Corrections (DAC) has
“certified” twenty-one alleged prison gangs as Security Risk Groups.
Prisoners are validated as members of SRG’s by Prison Intelligence
Officers (PIO) who are usually white, whose discretion reigns supreme in
determining who is validated as SRG members and who isn’t. These
subjective decisions lead to disproportionate validations of New Afrikan
prisoners and those from other oppressed nations. A stark example of the
racially uneven application of SRG validations is evident in the
percentage of “white” prisoners who have been validated compared to New
Afrikan prisoners. White prisoners make up 1.9% of the prisoners
validated in NC prisons.
Around the world gangs are studied by those with specialized training
in areas such as ethnography, anthropology, and psychology. In these
fields, researchers are often subjected to ethical standards that warn
against manipulating data to advance their personal objectives and
required to employ social science field research best practices in
relation to data collection, analysis, and interpretation. The officers
responsible for validating prisoners are not held to any such ethical
standards and lack the fundamental knowledge to determine if a prisoner
is actually a SRG member or not.
The degree of specialized knowledge for these officers to be
qualified as “gang-experts” is particularly lacking. An officer can be
qualified as a “gang-expert” after having only a couple months on the
job, as long as they have some formalized training. You would think
these “gang officers” would be required to demonstrate a basic
overstanding of the complicated dynamics at issue where gang membership
and behavior are concerned beyond stereotypes and prototypes, being that
these validations subject prisoners to indefinite sanctions and
restrictions that not only affect the lives of the prisoners but also
the lives of the prisoners’ families.
These “gang officers” employ a worksheet which lists seventeen
criteria for determining gang involvement, each of which is assigned a
point value. Prisoners may be labeled as “suspects/associates” or
“members”. A qualifying score is not difficult to achieve: prisoners
bearing tattoos “thought” to signify gang affiliation and who socialize
with “confirmed” gang-members may be regarded as members themselves.
False positives are likely to arise under this criteria, because
while they may indicate a correlation with gang membership, they do not
establish causation. Because gang membership cannot be reliably inferred
from the factors aforementioned, these “gang officers” should not be
allowed to opine about gang membership based on these factors alone.
Completed validation worksheets are forwarded to the NCDAC’s Chief of
Special Operations, Daryll Vann, who reviews the worksheet, confirms
that “relevant” documentation is attached, and validates the
identifications. Prisoners who wish to contest the validation are not
afforded the opportunity to do so. Prisoners receive no notice of their
validation, no procedural due process, nor a periodic review that would
enable the prisoner to have the validation removed. Therefore, prisoners
who have been validated, remain validated for the duration of their
incarceration and irrevocably are subject to SRG policy
deprivations.
There are only two ways to have the SRG validation removed. There is
a SRG program that’s accessible to a limited number of prisoners. It is
a 9-month program at Foothills Correctional, a prison located in the
rural mountainous region of Western NC. The staff employed there are
exclusively white, live in race segregated communities and are out of
touch with the cultures of the prisoners they oversee.
When these “gang officers” walk through the doors of the prison, many
of them, knowingly or unknowingly, hold negative biases towards those
who have been validated and those who don’t look like them.
The media perpetuates inaccurate narratives of violence, criminality,
and dishonesty among racial minorities that many of these “gang
officers” unknowingly internalize. It shows in how they interact and
deal with the prisoners.
The DAC describes this program as being a program that “targets those
beliefs (cognitions) that support criminal behavior ….” and seeks to
shift the thinking that supports these beliefs. Prisoners who complete
this program must undergo a debriefing and renounce their affiliation,
if any, before the validation is removed. This program is not available
to prisoners who have been labeled problematic.
The other way to have the validation removed is to complete your
prison sentence and be discharged from NCDAC custody. Of the 1,343
prisoners released from NCDAC’s custody last year, 564 were alleged SRG
members.
Draconian Gang Policies
& Procedures
The ostensible purpose of the DAC’s SRG policies and procedures is to
avoid prison disturbances supposedly fomented by gangs. Nonetheless it
is obvious these policies and procedures have the effect of
incapacitating significant numbers of prisoners and has cultivated an
environment opposite from what prison officials claim to be “safer”.
Those who have been validated find themselves subjected to draconian
sanctions and restrictions, such as being prohibited from receiving
visits from anyone beyond immediate family. This excludes aunts, uncles,
cousins, and the mother of your child(ren). If you have no immediate
family members to accompany your child(ren) to visitation you will not
be allowed to visit with them. Our childrens’ interests are not, as a
matter of right, factored into SRG validation determinations. The fact
that parent-child visitation can help children overcome the challenges
of parental separation and reduce recidivism rates is well-documented.
However, prison officials find it plausible to implement such a policy
that prevents parent-child visits.
As with the prisoners who have been validated, New Afrikan children
are the ones greatly affected by this policy. NCDAC has implemented this
policy without any cognizance that such a restriction may implicate the
parent-child relationship, which is typically subject to extraordinary
protection by the courts. But yet this policy goes unchecked.
During my incarceration i’ve been unable to visit with my daughter
due to me having no immediate family willing to accompany her. This has
prevented her and i from developing a meaningful relationship. This is
something that a majority of us are experiencing.
Moreover, this policy has an outsized impact on New Afrikan families
and other members of marginalized communities who bear the brunt of mass
incarceration.
Limiting a prisoner’s visitors to immediate family only effectively
cuts a prisoner off from family members who may have raised them. As we
know in marginalized communities there are an overwhelming amount of
fractured families, where grandparents and others play the mother-father
role.
Then there are the prisoners who were raised in foster care, who have
never had the opportunity to meet their immediate family. There is no
exception for foster care parents.
Although these restrictions are sometimes justified, they are being
used indiscriminately without individual analysis.
On 19 February 2019, a policy was implemented that prohibited
validated prisoners from receiving monetary support from anyone who
wasn’t an approved visitor.
Prison officials claimed that this was done to curtail “Black Market”
activities and strong arming. It’s not difficult to see how such a
policy would increase said activities and, moreover, would create an
environment where those who do have means of receiving financial support
become victims of strong arming and other acts of violence.
This policy was implemented 8 months prior to now-retired Director of
Prisons Kenneth Lassiter requesting more funding for security and
control weapons. During these 8 months, violence amongst prisoners
drastically increased, i know because a majority of the close-custody
facilities were placed on lockdown due to the increased violence.
Validated prisoners are prohibited from attending all
educational/vocational programs, compelled to serve idle prison
sentences. They are locked in their cells virtually all of the time and
otherwise maintained in extremely harsh conditions. Unable to have their
custody level reduced to medium or minimum security. And job
opportunities are non-existent. Common sense would tell prison officials
that there are many reasons to believe that these policies and
restrictions will produce unfortunate results both inside and outside of
prison.
The Ramifications of these
Policies
Motivated by an inaccurate conception of gangs and how they operate,
the NCDAC has adopted policies that have enhanced group cohesiveness and
the identities of gang-affiliated prisoners. These policies have
promoted new gang connections for prisoners who, due to the difficulties
inherent in gang identification, inadequate procedures and racial
stereotyping, are misidentified. The validated prisoner tells emself
“they think i’m a gang member, i might as well be one”. Of course these
policies raise obvious moral and ethical questions. However, i would
like to focus on how these policies make no sense from a correctional
perspective. Even if these “gang officers” are creating or enhancing
gang identities, why does it matter? Validated prisoners maintained in
these locked down blocks, after all, are effectively disabled from
committing acts of misconduct when locked in their cells.
Validated prisoners are denied access to visitation, financial
support, transfers to medium or minimum custody, as well as parole. They
have nothing more to lose so they are not deterred by any threat of
punishment, what else can be taken from them? They have no incentive to
refrain from gang involvement?
Aside from prison concerns, the impact of these policies’
ramifications will be felt most profoundly on the streets and
communities to which these prisoners will return. As i pointed out, 564
of the 1,343 prisoners released from NCDAC’s custody last year were
alleged gang members. In general, 96% of all prisoners return to
society. There are recidivism studies focusing on gang affiliated prison
releases, that show that gang members may retain their gang identity
upon their release. (see: Salvador Buentello et. al, “Prison Gang
Development: A Theoretical Model”, The Prison Journal,
Fall-Winter 1991, at 3.8.) Thus, these policies not only fail to enhance
prison security, they also undermine public safety.
We Have A Responsibility
All across the United $tates, prisoners themselves are subjected to
similar sanctions and restrictions under the guide of enhancing prison
security. i’ve revealed how these policies target New Afrikan prisoners
and others of the oppressed nations and how they affect not only the
prison but their families and communities as well. We have the numbers,
we have the capability and we have the know how to bring about change.
But as Komrade George Jackson expressed:
“We all seem to be in the grip of some terrible quandary. Our enemies
have so confused us that we seem to have been rendered incapable of the
smallest responsibility. I see this irresponsibility, or mediocrity at
best[, as] disloyalty, self-hatred, cowardice, competition between
themselves, resentment of any who may have excelled in anything….”
Because of the inexorable nature of our overseers, nationwide
demonstrations on the outside and within these walls is presently
necessary if we are to correct the correctors.
We have united fronts such as the United Front For Peace in Prisons,
the United Struggle Within (USW) and Prison Lives Matter (PLM). PLM is a
united front for political prisoners, prisoners of war, politicized
individuals behind the walls of these razor-wire plantations and their
organizations, as well as any outside formations in union with the
struggles of prisoners, that has made it possible for us to address and
redress the inhumane living conditions we find ourselves subjected to.
It’s on us to initiate the process, it’s on us to communicate and
network with one another, to get on the same page, so we can unite a
page in the history books.
A Call to Action
As we grapple with an expanding and increasingly repressive prison
system here in North Carolina, any hope for change lays in perfecting
ourselves – our physical care, intellectual acumen, and cultural
proficiency – while simultaneously confronting our overseers. And as i
aforesaid, “There is no silver bullet or magic wand that can be used to
expedite the transformation that must be made.” We have a personal
responsibility to contribute to the confronting that must be done.
Some of us don’t seem to know what side we’re on. We’re obsessed with
near-sighted disputes based on race, gang affiliation and so on. We
expend our energies despising and distrusting each other. All of this is
helping the NCDAC. We permit them to keep us at each others throats. i
am calling for unity. We outnumber them. Wake up!!! Put your prejudices,
biases, and gang affiliation aside for the purpose of OUR fight with the
NCDAC. i’m asking we start by submitting a grievance concerning NCDAC’s
SRG policies and procedures (an example has been provided below).
Of course i’m not expecting any redress from submitting grievances.
NCDAC’s Administrative Remedy Procedure process is ineffective and
honestly a waste of time if you are seeking redress. However, i’ve not
asked you to submit said grievance with hopes that NCDAC officials will
correct their wrongs.
i’m currently in the middle of litigating a civil suit against NCDAC
on behalf of all prisoners who have been validated as a SRG member. By
submitting a grievance you will be supporting the claims i have made.
Thusly i entrust you take the time and submit the following grievance
(and send a copy to MIM(Prisons) if you can):
In the early hours of Wednesday, December 4th, a masked gunman shot
the CEO of United $tates insurance company UnitedHealthcare, Brian
Thompson, to death in the bustling streets of New York City. By midday,
CCTV footage of the act had gone viral across the internet and
traditional news media, spawning endless narratives and theories.
Simultaneously, the high-profile nature of the shooting prompted a
national manhunt to search for the suspect. The shooter evaded capture
for five days, but ey was eventually arrested after a tip was called in
by a McDonald’s employee in rural Pennsylvania.
As communists operating in the United $tates, how are we to
understand this event? What does the event itself and its resulting
fallout tell us about the political landscape we work within? If we wish
to live up to the title of being Marxists, the only answer to these
questions is that we must conduct a, as Lenin put it, “concrete analysis
of concrete conditions.” Let us begin with the facts of the case.
The Facts
The name of the alleged shooter is Luigi Mangione. As laid out in eir
so-called ‘manifesto’, Luigi’s motivation for the shooting is a disdain
for U.$. healthcare insurance companies in general and UnitedHealthcare
in particular. The origin of this disdain likely lies in a combination
of Luigi’s persynal interactions with health insurance companies through
eir struggles with back pain as well as the more widespread antagonism
between the U.$. population and health insurance companies.
Luigi comes from a well-connected family which has its roots in the
suburbs of Baltimore, Maryland. Eir grandfather ran several successful
business ventures which guaranteed employment and prosperity for the
next generations of the Mangione family as they have now taken the reins
on the family businesses. Luigi emself attended a private high school
before attending the Ivy League University of Pennsylvania where ey got
eir degree in computer science in 2020. According to Luigi’s family and
friends, ey ceased all communication with them in July 2024. Presumably,
Luigi spent the time between then and December planning the shooting,
which we will now focus on.
As mentioned, the shooting itself took place on the morning of 4
December 2024. Interestingly, Luigi employed a 3D-printed firearm to
commit the shooting, which marks the first time such a weapon has been
used in such a high-profile case. Immediately after, Luigi evaded the
swarms of police by traveling via foot, cab, and e-bike before boarding
a train towards Philadelphia. Not much else is known about Luigi’s
whereabouts and travels during the 5 days between the shooting and eir
arrest in Altoona, Pennsylvania.
The biggest takeaway here is how easily Luigi evaded both the NYPD
and the FBI for an extended period of time. If Luigi had continued
traveling, discarded the evidence ey carried on em, or put any effort
into changing eir appearance, it’s likely that ey would have never been
caught. But this is simply speculation on our parts. Let us now turn
from the objective facts of the case to the realm of ideology.
Luigi’s Ideology
To understand why Luigi Mangione shot Brian Thompson, we must first
understand eir ideology. The only clues we have towards this
understanding are scattered social media posts as well as the
aforementioned “manifesto” Luigi had on em when ey was arrested. While
we’ll primarily focus on the “manifesto”, we will first highlight one of
Luigi’s social media posts where ey reviews the writings of Ted
Kaczynski, also known as the Unabomber. In this review, Luigi highlights
how Kaczynski was “rightfully imprisoned” because ey “maimed innocent
people” but that these were the actions of an “extreme political
revolutionary.” Luigi’s review finishes by quoting multiple paragraphs
from a Reddit comment expounding how violence is the only method we have
at our disposal to fight back against “our overlords.”
Now, turning to the “manifesto”, we wish to give our readers the
fullest picture possible, so we have included below a full copy of the
writing that was recovered when Luigi was arrested:
“To the Feds, I’ll keep this short, because I do respect what you do
for our country. To save you a lengthy investigation, I state plainly
that I wasn’t working with anyone. This was fairly trivial: some
elementary social engineering, basic CAD, a lot of patience. The spiral
notebook, if present, has some straggling notes and To Do lists that
illuminate the gist of it. My tech is pretty locked down because I work
in engineering so probably not much info there. I do apologize for any
strife of traumas but it had to be done. Frankly, these parasites simply
had it coming. A reminder: the US has the #1 most expensive healthcare
system in the world, yet we rank roughly #42 in life expectancy. United
is the [indecipherable] largest company in the US by market cap, behind
only Apple, Google, Walmart. It has grown and grown, but as [sic] our
life expectancy? No the reality is, these [indecipherable] have simply
gotten too powerful, and they continue to abuse our country for immense
profit because the American public has allwed [sic] them to get away
with it. Obviously the problem is more complex, but I do not have space,
and frankly I do not pretend to be the most qualified person to lay out
the full argument. But many have illuminated the corruption and greed
(e.g.: Rosenthal, Moore), decades ago and the problems simply remain. It
is not an issue of awareness at this point, but clearly power games at
play. Evidently I am the first to face it with such brutal
honesty.”(1)
Let us take a closer look at this writing. Luigi begins with
saying:
“To the Feds, I’ll keep this short, because I do respect what you do
for our country.”
To those who proclaim Luigi is spreading “class consciousness” or
that ey is a revolutionary, this single sentence should shatter all
illusions. If an ally of yours said ey respects federal agents (of the
FBI, CIA, etc.) for what they “do for our country,” would you be on eir
side? Our answer to this question is a resounding Fuck
No.
What else does Luigi write about? Ey brings up some rudimentary
statistics about life expectancy in the United $tates and market
capitalization before asserting that U.$. corporations have “gotten too
powerful” and “they continue to abuse our country for immense profit
because the American public has allwed [sic] them to get away with it.”
This strikes us as similar to the proposition that the Amerikkkan public
is “brainwashed” (how? by whom? why?) into merely passively accepting
the capitalist-imperialist world-system. This stands in opposition to
our political line which is that Euro-Amerikans actively embrace
imperialism (consciously or not) as the primary source of their wealth
via super-profits extracted from the Third World proletariat.
Luigi ends eir writing by admitting that ey is not “the most
qualified person to lay out the full argument” for the issues of the
U.$. health insurance system but assures us that ey is, “evidently […]
the first to face it with such brutal honesty.”
How high and mighty! Luigi is “evidently” the first to break through
the veil of ignorance which plagues the rest of us. Though we would
contend that there are perhaps a few people who have come before
Mr. Mangione who have faced the “corruption and greed” of the healthcare
industry (which is only a particular form of capitalist industry in
general) with “such brutal honesty.” Off the top of our heads, we can
think of Marx, Engels, Lenin, Stalin, Mao, Fred Hampton, Malcolm X, or
Huey Newton, just to name a few. These are of course only the most
popular figureheads of past communist movements. In reality, there are
millions who have stood their ground against the imperialist-bourgeoisie
and lost their lives for it. But no matter their sacrifice, for we have
been blessed with the gift of the wealthy Euro-Amerikan from Maryland
showing us the path forward!
So where does all this leave us? Is Luigi really a Marxist
revolutionary who has been sent down from the Heavens to end the
oppression of the masses? Of course not. Luigi’s writings and musings
are nothing more than regurgitations of the same social fascist populism
that is reminiscent of the messaging around Bernie
Sander’s presidential campaigns combined with an impetus towards
political violence. Discontent with the healthcare insurance industry is
normal everyday politics for people living in the United $tates. All
Luigi did was elevate this discontent from the level of complaining on
the internet or attending protests to killing a CEO. An escalation of
force, to be sure, but not one that is qualitatively different in its
nature.
The Public’s Reaction
However critical we may be of Luigi Mangione, ey is only an
individual. It would be an error to narrowly focus on the individual
agents of hystory rather than the political trends and their material
causes which compel individuals to act the way they do. So what trend
underlies the actions of Luigi? And how has this been reflected in the
public’s reaction to the killing?
Broadly, reactions to the shooting can be grouped into one of two
camps: condemnations of Luigi’s actions or celebrations of them.
Those who condemn Luigi tend to do so from a position of superficial
pacifism wherein you must be totally against violence in all situations
– unless it benefits yourself or your nation. A vast majority of U.$.
politicians fall into this group as well as a sizable portion of the
U.$. citizenry. Typically hailing from the upper strata of U.$. society,
these individuals are largely hypocritical and uninteresting for our
purposes here. After all, even a child can identify the contradiction
that’s present when one mourns the death of a single CEO while
simultaneously advocating for imperialist armies to indiscriminately
murder the oppressed.
On the other side, there are large swaths of people who view Luigi as
a “folk hero” or a “savior” and exist somewhere on the spectrum between
sympathizing with or admiring Luigi. Typically viewed as part of the
Amerikan “left” (though we have observed both Democrats and Republicans
expressing these views), this group wishes for healthcare reform in
order to ease up on the contradictions intrinsic to the capitalist
system. More specifically, these individuals fall into the same category
of social fascist labor aristocrats as Luigi. Their class status as
labor aristocrats is being threatened by the “greedy” capitalists of the
health insurance corporations who want to take away their hard-earned
wealth (i.e. superprofits from the Third World) and Luigi’s actions are
simply one response to this threat. So long as their aim is narrowly
limited on what can be done to improve the lives of Amerikans rather
than taking a revolutionary approach to understand what can be done to
improve the lives of all humyns, they remain enemies of the
international proletariat.
This graph helps illustrate the demographics of either group as well
as the proportions of the U.$. population that fall into either side. We
also must wonder if the 20% support for Luigi Mangione among Amerikans
would translate to support for retribution for the killing of Robert
Brooks by New York prison guards and the slow genocide of New
Afrikan men in U.$. prisons? We probably all know the answer to this
question.
Though there is a real ideological divide between the two
aforementioned groups, it would be wrong to overstate the width of this
divide. Both groups are merely two factions of the white supremacist
Amerikkkan establishment which exploits the Third World in order to
secure their own prosperity.
Our Thoughts
Where do we lie in this divide? You certainly won’t find us shedding
tears over a dead CEO, disavowing violence, or proclaiming pacifism, but
you also will not see us celebrating Luigi Mangione as some sort of hero
of the oppressed. Instead, we view Luigi as merely the latest
manifestation of labor aristocracy angst towards the imperialist leaders
of the United $tates. If either of Luigi’s actions or political line
were rooted in revolutionary politics, we’d be a bit more sympathetic to
em. But as it stands, Luigi’s lone wolf killing is both tactically inept
and ideologically confused.
More broadly, we understand the struggle of people in the United
$tates for more comprehensive healthcare. But rather than trying to
secure healthcare for Amerikans only, why don’t we set our sights on
securing healthcare for all people? Why should we advocate for petty
reforms like getting earlier colonoscopies for middle-aged Amerikans
when millions die each year in the Third World from easily-preventable
diseases because of imperialist wealth extraction? or when U.$. weapons
are used to murder doctors and bomb hospitals in Gaza? This is a topic
comrades have written
on before in relation to the Affordable Care Act(3), and it clearly
remains relevant today. Even if we limit our scope to be within U.$.
borders, the lack of healthcare that’s available for prisoners is a much
more pressing issue than the reforms which the social fascists are
seeking. It’s well documented how healthcare,
and lack thereof, is used as a tool to punish and torture
prisoners(4) rather than being recognized as a constitutional
right.
Circling back to the central topic of this article, the question
still stands: will this shooting actually change anything about the
healthcare industry? Almost certainly not. But it has provided an
opportunity for the fascism of the labor aristocracy to rear its head in
a particularly brazen fashion through the actions of Luigi Mangione. As
the U.$. labor aristocracy is faced with political chaos both at-home
and abroad, they will resist the ever-looming threat of
proletarianization. Will they recover and maintain their position in the
imperialist world system? Will the U.$. population come face-to-face
with proletarianization as global inter-imperialist conflicts intensify?
We cannot say which is the case. The only thing we are sure of is that
the actions of Luigi Mangione have provided a unique insight into the
political terrain we operate in within U.$. borders. As communists, we
must harness this insight and use it to guide our political action so
that we may empower the international proletariat in their struggle
against capitalist-imperialism. The only path forward is revolution.
Some of the problems I have run into organizing are being targeted by
administration for conducting a study group. Some times there’s too many
people interested for the space available, then when you’ve got 15-20
people huddled up and no violence is occurring, it scared the C.O.’s
They are not used to that type of unity and they don’t encourage
anything that has to do with building a collective consciousness. I try
to do study groups in smaller circles and more discreetly because some
dudes are eyes and ears for the oppressor. Repression is not a good
thing at all and I must say that before I continue. However, when they
do crack down, that’s when I pay close attention because certain
responses help me inventory the caliber of men I’m studying with. The
ones who know and understand the full magnitude of what the consequences
can be for orchestrating a study group but are still willing to carry on
are my type of comrades. In other words, the targeting helps me see
who’s who.
As far as the question of being surrounded by enemies, we can list
the various forces inside prisons similar to classes/nations outside
because there are different types of people and not everybody is on the
same page. For example, if in the prison I am housed at I did a united
front for Palestine solidarity, certain people would not even consider
it because that’s not the level of struggle they are interested in. But
if I did one for, let’s say, advocating for more quality programming
inside the institution, you will see a different crowd. Even in this
crowd, you will have some who fully identify with capitalist principles
(even fascism) and their oppressor.
Different initiatives will attract different people. I feel like it’s
important to dichotomize because not everybody is qualified for
revolutionary work. You’ve got some people who are so broken and
battered they will utilize this as an opportunity to gain favor with the
oppressor. United fronts can be formed that resolve around us
understanding our personal experiences within the criminal injustice
system and putting it in a larger context of abolishing the prison
system and all other oppressive, capitalist-imperial systems. By us
connecting this link to the outside world, we will see how these systems
overlap and the need for a united front for all the oppressed. The fight
continues.
MIM(Prisons) responds: Last issue we asked for feedback
on what it was like to build support for Palestine in prisons. As this
comrade indicates, it can be a hard sell. Focusing on quality
programming can be a better place to start, but it is not inherently
going to build the movement. More programming can lead to more state
control over what prisoners are doing with their time, more
brainwashing. So such a campaign would need to have a component where
you were also building programs, or just space for discussion, that
serves the movement for it to be a progressive campaign. That is, a
campaign that serves the international proletariat rather than something
that just helps a small group of people get jobs when they’re released
or whatever. Campaigning for Palestine is much more inherently
internationalist in its content, and it does not present these
challenges – it presents the challenge of being harder to mobilize
people around instead as comrades in Texas and Florida have also
reported.
by a North Carolina prisoner January 2025 permalink
Greetings,
I was given a couple copies of the Under Lock and Key by my homie. He
had encouraged me to read them and then write into MIM(Prisons) with my
own letter/article. I’m new to the topics that were discussed in
ULK and the overall prison movement, however, since the bro was
moved in the block he has been browbeating me with how important it is
to be involved in bettering our own conditions and self-educating
myself.
After giving it some thought I decided to write in about something
that bothers me the most. I’ve been incarcerated now since 10 May 2022
and I’ve yet to receive a visit from any of my friends or loved ones due
to this policy which the North Carolina Department of Adult Corrections
(NCDAC) have put in place. Those who want to visit must first be
approved before they are eligible. There are a lot of stipulations to
this process and if these stipulations aren’t met then the person will
be disapproved, therefore ineligible to visit. This also determines if
you will be able to receive money from the outside due to another one of
NCDAC’s policies, said policy only allowing us to receive financial
support from approved visitors.
We as Black People, I mean New Afrikans, know we come from
communities where at least one if not two of our immediate family
members have been convicted of a crime resulting in them having a
criminal record. This is one of the stipulations that prevent someone
from being approved for visitation.
My wife was convicted of a crime therefore she isn’t allowed to visit
with me nor am I allowed to visit with my children due to her not being
allowed to visit me. And as I mentioned she’s also unable to send me
money. The latter causing me to be placed on long-term segregation
because I had to get my necessities by any means. The prison officials
who make up these policies do so without caring about how the policy
will affect us, our family, and our rehabilitation process. I had a
guard tell me he feels my pain, BS you can’t feel my pain unless you’ve
felt my pain and none of them have because they are able to go home to
their family every day, while an individual like me can’t even receive a
visit from my loved ones.
Let me give you a scenario. You are a prisoner, you get a letter from
your mother telling you that she is sick and her health isn’t too good.
She expresses how she would love to visit with you and asks why she
can’t, you have to explain the aforementioned policy to her the best you
can. A couple months pass and you are notified by family that your
mother’s health worsens, she has to be hospitalized. There are no video
visits despite us having tablets that are equipped to have them and your
mother still hasn’t been approved for visitation. You are worried you
may never get to see your mother again. The days pass, you are on seg
because you need hygiene so you attempted to hustle, however you were
caught. The guard comes to your door, tells you to get dressed as the
chaplain needs to see you. We all know this isn’t good. You get dressed
and go out to visit the chaplain, he tells you your mother has passed
and gives you a brief 5-min call to speak to your family. You are taken
back to your cell unable to attend the funeral and never being able to
see your mother again.
This is such a cruel scenario right? Well it’s no scenario at all,
this is what has happened to me.
Like I said at the beginning I’m new to the Prison Movement, this
struggle, but I’m not new to pain and oppression. I will never get to
see my mother again but I can help get things changed to where a
scenario doesn’t become someone’s reality.
I see how my big bro struggles day in and day out trying to raise the
consciousness of our peers and unite them and I understand why he does
it now. And with me knowing this I promise to struggle as well.
In closing I’d like to say for those who are new to the movement
write into MIM and request old issues of the ULK. They will
help you get a better understanding of what it takes and what it is
we’re struggling for.
MIM(Prisons) responds:Welcome to the movement comrade!
Another comrade in South Carolina just wrote regarding similar
punishments towards those labelled “Security Threat Group” or STG there.
We also had a comrade in Indiana who was recently denied
a contact visit with eir dying mother because ey was in segregation.
People losing family members this way while in prison is something many
of us have experienced. So we see these practices are common in the
United $tates.
As the author points out these practices de facto target oppressed
people, especially the New Afrikan nation that is disproportionately
targeted by the criminal justice system. They are part of a low
intensity genocide on the internal semi-colonies, and a system that
fails to help society in the way it impacts all who find themselves
locked inside it.
Just a few months ago we reported on the ongoing
illegal funding of I$rael by the United $tates, with a recently
announced $8.7 billion funding package. As Biden prepares to leave
office later this month, it has been reported that another $8 billion is
being sent to fund the imperialist outpost in the Middle East. Axios
reports:
“The State Department has notified Congress ‘informally’ of an $8
billion proposed arms deal with Israel that will include munitions for
fighter jets and attack helicopters as well as artillery shells.”
The Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) responded in
part:
“Only racists who do not view people of color as equally human, and
sociopaths who delight in funding mass slaughter, could send Netanyahu
even more bombs while his government openly kidnaps doctors, destroys
hospitals, and exterminates the last survivors in northern Gaza.”(1)
The Palestinian resistance has drawn the line in the sand, and are
continuing to expose the racism of Amerikans and others in the
imperialist countries who support this ongoing genocide. But it is
especially the people in the United $tates who benefit from the funds
feeding the military industrial complex, as most aid to I$rael is spent
here.
In further support of militarism on his way out of office, Biden has
once again begun direct bombing of Yemen by U.$. war ships despite a
pledge to end the war on Yemen when campaigning for the presidency. As
part of Operation Prosperity Guardian, U.$. aircraft carriers have been
in the Red Sea for over a year to safeguard international trade in
general and shipments to I$rael in particular. Recently, the Amerikans
bombed both the only airport in Yemen, killing six and injuring 40, and
the main port that serves as the lifeline for getting supplies to Yemen.
This port was already largely damaged in the ongoing war with the
U.$.-backed Saudi regime. The airport attack was timed by I$rael to
happen while the World Health Organization General Secretary was there,
though ey was not injured.(2)
Despite over 22 years of continuous U.$.-sponsored attacks, the
people of Yemen stand strong, and Ansar Allah are clear they will not
stop rerouting ships in the Red Sea and attacking I$rael until genocide
in Gaza stops.
There is no hope of the U.$. imperialists cutting off I$rael on their
own volition, and everything in our power must be done here in the heart
of empire to stop the funding of genocide and the expansionist settler
colonialism spreading across the region. Palestine, Yemen and others in
the region are at the front lines fighting imperialism and
oppression.
Robert Brooks, a 43 year old New Afrikan man, was beaten to death by
Correctional Officers (C.O.s) in Marcy Correctional Facility in upstate
New York on 9 December 2024, dying in the hospital the next day. On 27
December the New York Attorney General’s office released body camera
footage from 6 C.O.s and 2 Sergeants involved in the beating. They show
Brooks being pinned to a gurney, while handcuffed, and beaten on-and-off
for many minutes by the pigs.(1) Thirteen staff members of the New York
State Department of Corrections and Community Supervision (DOCCS) are
being investigated in the beating.(2)
Marcy C.F. is in an area of upstate New York known for its racist
rednecks, a very white area abutting the Oneida Nation Reservation. Just
down the road is the infamous Clinton Correctional Facility as well as
the Mohawk Correctional Facility offensively named after the neighboring
Mohawk nation of the Iroquois confederacy. A comrade struggling with
addiction was moved from Mohawk last year to a Secure Housing Facility
where ey reports:
“I still am recovering from the brutal assault, battery, torture and
sexual assault by the gang of pigz here at Upstate C.F. I am physically
healing slowly and taking some drug to help with the brain damage I
suffered from all the fractures in my face and forehead. I’m doing
physical therapy for my arm. My studies with you all have given me the
focus and strength to recover. I am no longer on the Suboxone program,
smoking cigarettes, marijuana or PCP. I still struggle with K2, but the
more time I spend grounded in studies, writing and reading with you all,
the less time I have to think about wanting to get high. I thank you all
and hope my struggle is an example to those who are sick themselves and
struggling.”
Brooks had recently been transferred from Mohawk as well, and sent to
Marcy this month.(2) The state investigation indicates that Brooks did
not attack the officers or do anything to warrant the use of force,
which the videos show as well.(1,2) Brooks’s death is suspected to be a
result of “asphyxia due to compression of the neck.” New York State
Correctional Officers are required to wear body cameras and have them
running whenever encountering a prisoner. While many involved covered
their cameras, the beating continued despite the presence of the body
cameras in the room. The Times Union reports that the C.O.s
seemed to be unaware that their body cameras could be passively
recording the incident.(2)
People posted pictures of Mario and Luigi cartoon characters online
in response to pictures and videos of the beating posted online. The
outrage at this state-sponsored lynching is somewhat encouraging, but
posting images online obviously won’t solve the brutality waged against
oppressed nations, and against prisoners in general, in this country.
Organization is needed. Only together can we protect ourselves.
I want to bring it to your attention that the “Restorative Housing”
unit at Nottoway Correctional Center in Burkeville, Virginia is
operating its solitary confinement unit in total conflict with state
law, see Virginia Code Section 53.1-39.2.
I just spent 68 days in solitary confinement. I requested an
accommodation for my healthcare, the pod they wanted to assign me to
offered no accommodation, so they put me into solitary confinement under
“protective” status. I was kept in a barren cell without anything to do
– no books, games, or other activities. My orthotics were taken for
“security reasons” preventing me from participating in out of cell
activities. I had nothing to do but eat, sleep, and read my mail.
State law requires that persons in solitary confinement be allowed
similar opportunities for activities, movement and social interaction as
general population when housed under protective status. State law also
allows persons under protective status to opt out of solitary
confinement at any time. Also, state law requires that prison officials
place persons housed under protective status in less restrictive housing
within a week or provide damn good reason why they didn’t.
For 68 days, I was denied similar opportunities for activities, etc.
I was never offered less restrictive housing. Upon realizing I was being
kept under unlawful conditions, I demanded to opt out of solitary
confinement only to be held for many more weeks. And I am not alone in
this situation.
There were eight of us in the pod with me on protective status. All
of us had been in there for many weeks. Two days before our release the
prison underwent an audit by DOC HQ. I caught one of the auditors and
explained all of this to him. Two days later prison officials released
six of us, placing me into housing that somewhat accommodates my
healthcare needs.
I don’t know what you can do to shed light on this, but please do
what you can. It’s important that the truth of this torture chamber come
to light. No one should be forced to endure what I was forced to
endure.
I recently read a writing titled: “Law, Prison and Double-Double
Consciousness: A Phenomenological View of the Black-Prisoner’s
Experience” by James Davis III. This led me to write the following:
“What I pondered was my own double-double consciousness! The
development of the”New Afrikan” within the greater black populace of
captives. From the taking of the Afrikan attribute(s)’s learning of
Ki-Swahili, the mandated study of all things dealing with black culture,
history and struggle, to the daily remaking of one’s world view through
study and application…the identity of “New Afrikan” implores one to rise
above the lowly station of inmate, of n-word.”
In reading this piece by Mr. Davis, I was reminded of the innate
power of a man. The power to literally reinvent oneself within an
environment designed to annihilate the soul of a man. Prison(s) are
created with a purpose to force a human to willingly acquiesce to
half-man existence.
To develop a double-double consciousness is to resist such inferior
station(s), to be a man! One who stands on principle(s), personified
purpose, and willingly accepts his responsibilities to both uplift and
reeducate the masses, which is a revolutionary ideal!
To embrace a revolutionary ideological precept is to strive even
harder at evolving this “double-double consciousness”. Aside from the
aforementioned character improvement(s), the revolutionary-minded man
immerses himself in all things dealing with progressive politics and the
science of struggle.
As his prison cohorts grow comfortable living captive man half-lives
(i.e. embracing typical prison activities: gambling, drug usage, etc.)
the revolutionary-minded captive creates a compass of consciousness
which guides him daily. He spends his time always pushing himself to
excel, regardless of tasks or conditions.
This is the cat who aligns with other men who reject the half-lives
and/or inferior designations expected of the captive class. Whenever
he/they are seen, they’re reading something, writing something,
attending college, engaging in some form of constructive dialogue, or
physically training their bodies. Forging his new self: the unbroken,
unbowed man that’s living and potentially dying, upon revolutionary
standards and practices.
The identification of oneself as a militant, as a revolutionary
theorist, anchors oneself. As those around him list to-and-fro,
uncertain of their next move(s), the innate belief within the mind of
the man moving by a revolutionary compass is that he represents
something greater than himself. That he is a soldier that happens to be
behind enemy lines if you will: captured! It is through this perception,
that he re-imagines his reality, and in turn finds purpose in his every
action. He discovers the reservoir of resistance within which moves him
to set his personal bar of daily exemplary conduct higher than those
around him. Understanding his calling, devoting himself to the people.
To meeting their needs.
I find all of the above to be quite close to describing myself.
Though admittedly, I fall short of the mark most days. Being human, with
all of the subjectivisms that accompany it, at times, my objective
conditions threaten to overwhelm me. Yet it is the will to win, to
resist the “colonial mentality” which has historically impacted my ilk,
propels me to stand firm. Existing within a perpetual mode of
resistance!
In looking back, I can really see that I’ve been in a state of
rebellion my entire life! That I have never been one of those “go along
to get along” type of brothas. Unfortunately, this ingrained sense of
recalcitrance has led to many years of imprisonment and designations by
those of the oppressor class, as being anti social and/or suffering some
mystery “personality disorder”. To not be a shoe shine boy, a buck
dancing coon, a tom! The conventional roles assigned to the U.$.
man/woman of color! Is to be castigated by those in power, and/or
positions of authority.
I now fully comprehend this whole “double-double consciousness” as it
pertains to myself individually and my New Afrikan/black kinfolk!
Collectively! All colored folk whom live in capitalist society, which is
governed by those who use race and class as measurements of worth! Not
only adjust to the double consciousness of faux citizenry…they also
develop their own “double-double consciousness” to cope!
However, the one brutal fact which distinguishes the U.$. Black
man/woman from any other ethnic groups is the historical miscarriage of
chattel slavery! Our socio-cultural creation of a double-double
consciousness is our collective survival mechanism if you will. A way to
figuratively stay rooted in our Afrikan beginnings! Whilst literally
standing on the shoulders of the many, many activists, struggle-ists,
revolutionaries, and average citizens whom were wounded, imprisoned,
tortured, and murdered! For daring to dream of having freedom, justice
and equality! We repay the debt to our martyrs by clinging fiercely to
their memories, living within our “cocoon’s” of double-double
consciousness! Forging bonds with other forward thinking folk of Afrikan
ancestry. And then, united in purpose, teach others how to “escape” our
half life existences! Moving towards a revolutionary ideology and
corresponding actions as the conditions reveal the time to manifest
them! I stand firm within the confines of a satanic creation! Striving
to be the catalyst for progress and change. As I survive, only through
my own “double-double consciousness” cocoon.
MIM(Prisons) adds: Davis’s double-double consciousness
is a product of alienation through oppressive structures. These
oppressive structures isolate people from “the world”, putting them in a
new reality, with new rules and norms, that are generally worse than
“the world” they know in every way. This is in contrast to prisons in
socialist China – where people were encouraged (you might say coerced)
to study the outside world, to better understand their own actions and
find a new way to be in that world that is in line with the interests of
the people. In a socialist prison, criminals can focus on struggling
with themselves because they aren’t forced to struggle against the
oppression of the prison environment first.
We offer comrades support in developing the consciousness that is in
rebellion against the oppressive system. We offer Under Lock &
Key as a forum to connect with and share ideas with other
like-minded individuals. We have our Revolutionary 12 Steps
that is one tool for those trying to transform themselves into new
people. And we have books on revolutionary societies like China, and
their prison system, and how they were able to radically transform a
whole society. So if this comrade’s essay resonates with you, get
involved and get plugged in with these resources today!