This is an archive of the former website of the Maoist Internationalist Movement, which was run by the now defunct Maoist Internationalist Party - Amerika. The MIM now consists of many independent cells, many of which have their own indendendent organs both online and off. MIM(Prisons) serves these documents as a service to and reference for the anti-imperialist movement worldwide.
Grave of the Fireflies (Hotaru no haka - 1988)
Isao Takahata (dir.)
Nobody will confuse this animated Japanese film with a Disney cartoon.
Grave tells the sad story of two Japanese children orphaned by an
Amerikan bombing raid during World War II. Left to fend for themselves, they
slowly starve to death. However, like other films which simply try to convey
the horrors of war -- the German films Das Boot and Stalingrad
come to mind -- Grave makes no attempt to explain the causes of
wars and how they can be avoided in the future.
Because of that, MIM can't recommend the film, but we will say that it is
more progressive in the Amerikan context than in the Japanese. Grave
reminds Amerikans that the firebombing of Tokyo -- to say nothing of
Hiroshima and Nagasaki -- had brutal consequences for the civilian
population, on a scale far surpassing anything Amerikans have experienced.
It's a far cry from the jingoistic Pearl Harbor (2001), which
portrayed an Amerikan raid as a great spectacle over empty warehouses,
watched from afar by two kimono-clad women on a lazy afternoon.
In the Japanese context, Grave bolsters the prejudice that Japan was
the victim in the war. The children's father is a naval officer, and he is
simply portrayed as doing his duty and defending Japan. No mention is made of
Japan's imperial ambitions in Asia and the Pacific; no discussion of the rape
of Nanking, the occupation of Korea, etc. etc. When the older boy Seita
learns that Japan lost the war, he weeps, not believing that the invincible
Japanese empire could lose. Just as in the United $tates today, most children
in Japan and Germany brought up during World War II were taught to identify
with their militaristic governments, so there is nothing wrong with
acknowledging this fact -- but Grave does so without comment. The
scene where Seita breaks down could provoke outrage that the Japanese
militarists twisted his mind, but it could just as easily promote nostalgia
for the good old days when Japan had a strong navy and army.
One reviewer (out of over 100) on an internet message board argued that
Grave contained a subtle critique of great nation pride. If so, it was
too subtle, as most of the other comments did not pick up on this. Grave
suffers from what could be called the "Mother Courage" effect.
Mother Courage and Her Children is a play written by the German anti-
militarist Bertolt Brecht during World War II. The title character tries
everything she can in the context of war and capitalism to keep her
children alive, but by the end of the play, war has killed them all. The play
was intended as a critique of Mother Courage and a reminder that suffering
the horrors of war was not enough to teach people how to avoid it in the
future. When it premiered in the rubble of Berlin after the war, however,
audiences hailed Mother Courage as a heroic character, indicative of the
persistence of ordinary Germans to carry on with their lives as they always
had despite the trauma of defeat.
Although perhaps intended to challenge oppressor-nation complacency, as
Mother Courage was, Grave never goes beyond sentimental humanism.